R Z16526 and Subclades Project

Formerly R-P314 Haplogroup Project
  • 164 members

About us

The Early Tree

Analysis of ancient bones has identified SNP R-DF21, a long way upstream of SNP P314, as present in Rathlin Island, in the very north of Ireland, as early as about 1900 B.C. (and possibly 160 years more recent than this) and there is today a clear presence of DF21, in the form of at least one of its subclades, that of SNP FGC3213, in Scotland.  The next level on the phylogenetic tree below FGC3213 is currently defined by two SNPs: Z16532 and ZZ1. Our project tree, as updated from time to time and presented in conjunction with the McCarthy Surname Study's McCarthy R-L21 Group B at www.mccarthydna.wordpress.com/ , indicates that principal subgroups under ZZ1 are to be found in Scotland (the heavily populated subclade of SNP S3058) and Galway Bay (the subclade of S5456). The inference is that FG3213, if not also its 'parent', DF21, which is seen throughout the 'Isles, arrived first in Scotland or the north of Ireland from Continental Europe, though no theory can be discounted!

Since the start of NGS testing, SNP Z16532 had been just one of many "equivalent" SNPs comprising a bottleneck between FGC3213 and the breaking out into the many branches and twigs of the tree relating to our project. Then in June 2016 a Big Y test by 120418 Hatcher showed positive for Z16532 but negative for all further SNPs in this bottleneck. Since Hatcher's haplotype showed none of the many STR mutations which characterise the lineages of our interest we deemed this kit to be outside the realm of this project but have allowed - with gratitude for his testing - membership of this one Hatcher and have included his haplotype as Group 0 in the Y-DNA Results table. The numerous Hatchers and some possible Hatcher NPEs clearly belonging in this subclade should explore their further inter-relationships through the Hatcher project at htpps://www.familytreedna.com/public/Hatcher/default.aspx.

From consideration of STR mutations it has been clear that a cluster comprising kit 208773, a participant with German origin, members of a (Welsh) Griffith family and some other Welsh / English individuals branched off about half way through the aforementioned SNP bottleneck (or, one could argue, split the lineage in two). It is crudely estimated that this split occured about 1,000 B.C. This cluster forms Group 1 in our Y-DNA Results table, and SNP testing - first an R1b-DF21 SNP Pack test on kit 208773 and finally a Big Y test on kit 229327 Griffith - has now revealed which SNPs in the said bottleneck are positive and which negative for this group. SNP P314, the original headline SNP used to name this project, is among the negative ones; as a consequence, it has been replaced with Z16526, one of the positive ones, in the naming of our project. As yet this has not been reflected in update of some administrative aspects of the project, such as urls provided by FTDNA.

Continuing down the 'R-P314' lineage, a second branch off has been discovered in 2018, with P314 testing positive but Z16534 negative in Swedish kit 381572 and in that of a representative of the Ogan surname. Our one Heaney member has only tested 37 STR markers but also appears to belong with this group. All six Heaneys who participated in the ca. 2004 Trinity College, Dublin study by Bradley, McEvoy and others - which effectively founded genetic genealogy in Ireland - clearly had haplotypes associated with what we now know as the P314 (or Z16526) lineage, albeit determined then from just 14 STR markers, so it seems likely this P314+, Z16534- group would be their home. In a rearrangement of member subgrouping in July 2018, the Ogans, Heaney and Swedish member have all now been assigned to our Group 2.
 

Principal Tree Branches

Beyond Groups 0, 1 and 2, SNP Z16534 is found in association with the rare STR mutation of 15 to 16 repeating motifs at DYF395S1a, following which myriad surviving branches begin to be recognised. Two principal divisions initially occur, but these soon flourish:

1)     Group 3, which is marked by the equally rare 12 to 13 STR mutation at DYS 617. 

      Within this group, (sub)Group 3a denotes those who have tested or are predicted negative for SNP L362 (i.e. are said to be L362-). 

A little way down the stem of the Group 3 tree, and, thanks to another R1b-DF21 SNP Pack test identified as positive for SNPs Z29539, ZS4597 and ZS4600, but negative for L362 is Driscoll kit 21275.  Beyond this is point is Group 3b. However, before this flourishes there is another significant bottleneck of 8 SNPs, including L362. There are also at least as many SNPs which have not been reported in the Pack test on kit 21275.   Comparison of the frequency of occurrence of SNPs in Group 3 with that of parallel Group 4 (see below) during the same time frame suggests that a number of the Group 3 bottleneck SNPs may have occurred simultaneously or at least over a very short period, thus potentially skewing estimates of dates for the occurrence of Group 3 SNPs. There are at least twenty reliable SNPs between the occurrence of the DYS 617 mutation and the end of the bottleneck period; during this same period there are just five 111 marker STR mutations. A ratio of 1.5: 1 is more usually seen when averaged over a sufficient time period.

From the surnames occurring in Group 3b, and with Driscoll on the most recent branch of Group 3a, it is clear that the paternal lineage preserving the haplotype with DYS 617 =13 very likely resided in Munster, if not initially, then from early on in the bottleneck period. This period culminated in a split into two subclades, one identifiable with SNP A11018 and the other with SNP ZS4606. The phylogeny so closely matches the ancient genealogical tracts that it can be claimed that the renowned Ceallachán of Cashel (who died circa 954 A.D.) was the progenitor of all currently shown in Group 3b. So here, at least we are able to calibrate the timeline, with the subclades initiated with A11018 and ZS4606 and /or one of their respective 'equivalents' having been founded in the 10th century. Group 3b has therefore been subtitled Munster branch 1, with Cashel, in Co. Tipperary, pinpointing its earliest known domicile.

SNP A11018 marks subgroup 3b4 (formerly 3b1), largely populated by the 11% of Callahans / O'Callaghans who belong in this project.  It will be seen some Newmans in subgroup 3b4 are inter-related with the (O')Call(g)hans. Noonan (likely source of this Newman name) and Callahan share a provenance in the barony of Duhallow, in north-west Cork.

The ZS4606 subclade is that of the McCarthys.  It soon splits into two major subclades, one marked by SNP A5813 (Subgroup 3b2) and the other by SNP ZS4598 (3b3). These two SNPs are mutually exclusive and again there is excellent alignment with the ancient genealogies, the two subgroups being headed by two sons of Dónal Mór na Curra Mac Carthaigh born late in the 12th century A.D., namely Cormac Fionn and Dónal Gott respectively. SNP A5813 marks the MacCarthy Mór / Muskerry / Duhallow branch of the McCarthys and ZS4598 the MacCarthy Reagh / Sliochd Feidhlimidh one. It is safe to say that any other surnames found on the A5813 / ZS4598 trees must be McCarthy NPEs. For further discussion specific to McCarthys please see the McCarthy Surname Study (where they comprise McCarthy R-L21 Group B) at https://www.familytreedna.com/groups/mc-carthy-surname-study/about/results

The phylogeny is therefore regarded as irrefutable evidence of alignment with the O'Callaghan / MacCarthy relationship and the splitting of MacCarthys into two major sub-branches as indicated in the historical genealogies and summarised in the top section of Fig. 2 at  www.mccarthydna.wordpress.com/Note there is as yet no evidence of SNPs L362 or ZS4606 among McAuliffes, so their origin according to the same genealogies is unproven. 

The histories and ancient genealogical tracts (and of course internet articles which trot these out) tell us that Ceallachán of Cashel's paternal ancestry lies in the Eóghanachta Chaisíl (Eóghanacht of Cashel), tracing back via Conall Corc and Ailill Flann Bec to the second century Oilioll Olum and Eoghan Mór. While genetic genealogy has validated such a common origin for many other Munster surnames, their alignment stems from a sharing of SNP A541 and the Irish Type II haplotype. So although Ceallachán may have emerged from the peoples known as the Eóghanachta Chaisíl, his paternal ancestry, and thus that of the MacCarthy kings of Cashel and Desmond, was not shared with the O'Sullivans, O'Keeffes, O'Moriartys, or certain of the O'Mahonys and O'Donoghues (surnames which have multiple origins), etc. 

2)     Group 4, marked by SNP Z16533. 

Within Group 4 a mutation at DYS458, from 17 to 16 STRs, distinguishes the small Group 4a (comprising entirely Martins and Keenans) from the large Group 4b. DYS458 is a fast mutating marker, but its value here has proven a reliable guide (always subject to the possibility of later further mutations in individual cases) since before the time we had no SNP data to confirm the tree structure for Group 4. The recent availability of STR data extracted from Big Y-500 tests (FTDNA's Panel 6) has revealed a further STR mutation, 14 to 15 repeating motifs at FT289, which occurred at about he same time, following which Group 4b divides into two major subgroups, one defined by SNP Z16538 (leading to Groups 4b1 and 4b2) and the other by SNP BY23661 (leading to Groups 4b4 and 4b5). The surnames of participants testing or suspected positive for Z16538 suggest its provenance was the same area within Munster as that of Group 3b (if not the whole of Group 3) and Groups 4b1 and 4b2 are consequently subtitled Munster branches 2 and 3. Those with the BY23661 mutation, on the other hand, indicate a Scottish and possible N.W. England origin  (e.g. Eubanks, among the latter, although this might have arisen elsewhere in present day Britain).


In addition to Groups 4a, and 4b, Group 4x comprises a miscellany with the aforementioned DYS458 mutation (which could of course have occurred independently) but in which that at FT289 is either absent or as yet undetermined. The most distant known ancestor locations or surnames in this group indicate provenances from Munster to the northern tip of mainland Scotland!


Common to all in Group 4b1 (Munster branch 2) is a back mutation at DYS389-2, one of the three STR markers originally used to identify likely P314.2 participants (see the Introduction on our Background page) and a quite rare mutation at DYS 438 (12 to 13 STR motifs).


Group 4b2 is marked by SNP Z16525, and within this group are to be found Kennedy, Leahy and O'Meara families - the last two with name variants - all sharing the further SNP Z16523 and a quite rare 18 to 19 mutation at DYS587. Common to all the Leahys is SNP FGC14748, while the Kennedys and O'Mearas probably shared a common ancestor in whom a 34 to 33 STR mutation at DYS710 occurred before their lineages separated, although with this being another fast-mutating marker it might have occurred independently in their ancestries.


The diversity among the Kennedys suggests they share ancestry in a Cinnéide who lived late in the first millenium. This could not have been the same as the Cinnéides of Brian Boru(mu)'s family, although the 'seat' of the latter was not far away in the same area of Munster; these for sure had the Irish Type III haplotype associated with SNP L226. It is also to be noted that 8 of the 67 Kennedys tested in the Bradley and McEvoy study referenced above had the distinct haplotype associated with SNP P314.2 and since Group 4b2 is the only group in our project in which Kennedys are to be found, it seems likely they too would have been placed there had more advanced testing been available at the time. (The Bradley and McEvoy study did not test the stand-out markers which were later associated with the Irish Type III haplotype but 23 of the 67 are potential candidates for such an origin). 

   

Member subgrouping

Member subgrouping on the Y-DNA Results page and the Z16526 tree is based on the above referenced groupings and is summarised as follows:


Group No.

Description

0

SNP path tested / predicted R-DF21>FGC3213>Z16532, but Z16526 negative and no STR mutations characteristic of Z16526 lineages

1

SNP path tested / predicted R-DF21>FGC3213>Z16532>Z16526 but P314 and Z16534 negative

2

SNP path tested / predicted R-DF21>FGC3213>Z16532>Z16526>P314 but Z16534, Z16533 and Z29539 negative. DYS 617 = 12.

3a

SNP path tested / predicted R-DF21>FGC3213>Z16532>Z16526>P314>Z16534 but Z16533 and L362 negative. DYS 617 = 13

3b1

SNP path tested / predicted R-DF21>FGC3213>Z16532>Z16526>P314>Z16534>Z29539>L362>ZS4606 (but A5813 and ZS4598 negative)

3b2

SNP path tested / predicted R-DF21>FGC3213>Z16532>Z16526>P314>Z16534>Z29539>L362>ZS4606>A5813 (Progeny of Cormac Fionn Mac Cárthaigh)

3b3

SNP path tested / predicted R-DF21>FGC3213>Z16532>Z16526>P314>Z16534>Z29539>L362>ZS4606>ZS4598 (Progeny of Dónal Gott Mac Cárthaigh)

3bx

SNP path tested / predicted R-DF21>FGC3213>Z16532>Z16526>P314>Z16534>Z29539>L362>ZS4606; need to test SNP path beyond ZS4606

3b4

SNP path tested / predicted R-DF21>FGC3213>Z16532>Z16526>P314>Z16534>Z29539>L362>A11018 (O'Callaghans of Cloonmeen)

4a

SNP path tested / predicted R-P314>Z16534>Z16533 but Z16538 and BY23661 negative and FTY289 = 14

4b1

SNP path tested / predicted R-P314>Z16534>Z16533>Z16538 and DYS 438 = 13, but Z16525 negative. FTY289 = 15.  Munster Branch 2

4b2

SNP path tested / predicted R-P314>Z16534>Z16533>Z16538>Z16525. FTY289 = 15.  Munster Branch 3

4b4

SNP path tested / predicted R-P314>Z16534>Z16533>BY23661 but FGC19890 negative.

4b5

SNP path tested / predicted R-P314>Z16534>Z16533>BY23661>FGC19890.

4x

SNP path predicted R-P314>Z16534>Z16533. SNP testing required.

Note: ‘Munster Branch 1’ applies to all 3b subgroups.

Last updated 11 December 2018